September 2009 Home   Newsletters

December 2009

May 2010

President's Message
December Unit Meetings
Public Access Room (PAR) Workshops (Suzanne Marinelli)
Membership (Donna Oba)
Quarterly Membership Meeting - January 23, 2010 (Sue Dursin)
Act 244 Hawaii County ... Campaign Finanace Project (Sue Dursin & Sue Irvine)
Hawaii Ed Fund (Helen Hemmes & Sue Irvine)
LWV Treasurer's Report 10/17/2009

Act 244 Hawaii County Council Comprehensive Campaign Finanace Pilot Project

On November 5th, Barbara Wong, Executive Director of the Hawaii State Campaign Spending Commission, came to Hilo to present a public workshop on implementation of the pilot project for comprehensive public funding of Hawaii County Council races. Sue Dursin rose at 4 am to join Sue Irvine at the sessions. We attended with about 25 citizens including council members Enriques, Ford, Ikeda, Onishi, and a few staff from the County Clerk’s office.

Few potential candidates other than incumbents attended the workshop. A few more may have attended repeats of the session, but there was no publicity for these events locally (other than Sue Dursin’s calendar posts) and they were not listed on the County website calendar. Video explanations of Act 244 are now available at the Campaign Spending Commission’s website.

The Hawaii Elections Project, with funding from the LWV of Honolulu Education Fund, is presently seeking to hire an independent entity to monitor implementation of Act 244 as the State provided no money to monitor outcomes.

Sue Irvine and Sue Dursin have the following list of concerns as implementation of Act 244 proceeds:

  • Will the 200 signatures and $5 check or money order from voters in a candidate’s district required to trigger comprehensive funding prove too high a barrier for participation? Incumbents should be able to reach this amount of support, but lesser known candidates may have difficulty.

  • The act has been drastically underfunded ($300,000 maximum appropriation for 2010 election cycle.) This was unnecessary, as funds are available under the Campaign Spending Commission, without tapping scarce general funds. Underfunding will not be a problem if few candidates meet the rather daunting comprehensive public funding requirements. If many candidates meet the requirements, the money is to be handed out “first come, first served” which would certainly cause negative publicity.

  • (At our last board meeting, Hawaii County LWV declined to endorse Council member Pete Hoffman’s resolution asking the Legislature to raise the funding limit for 2010. The board was reluctant to act at that time, but there will likely be a statewide push for more funding after the 2010 election cycle. Hoffman’s resolution failed to pass.)

  • At this point, there has been little publicity on the Island concerning Act 244. This may be appropriate for now (see paragraph on underfunding – fewer candidates aware means less chance of funds being depleted.) We hope this lack of publicity is not because our Council Chair and County Clerk are on public record opposing Act 244. moment may leave the publicly funded candidate without the other 70% of funds promised, as all funding for the program may have been depleted by that time.

Aside from the above concerns, we were pleased to hear Barbara Wong, who also went on public record opposing Act 244, promise good support for candidates trying to qualify for comprehensive public funding. She stressed that candidates should continue checking the Campaign Spending Commission website for updates, where it appears good software should help file all campaign spending reports.

We look forward to the independent analysis of Act 244, although we have been somewhat concerned that, with the planning all based in Honolulu, knowledgeable people in Hawaii County need to be consulted – people such as lawyer Chris Yuen, and political scientists at UHH.

Sue Irvine
Sue Dursin

September 2009 Top   Home   Newsletters May 2010